Ethnic voting is more than just an electoral pattern. When accompanied by geographic concentration, separate community institutions, and an identity-based allegiance stronger than loyalty to the country’s civic identity, it may signal a failure of integration. In such cases, the community does not become part of the broader political society but instead maintains a parallel system of loyalties, norms, and political objectives, effectively creating a “state within a state”: an environment in which ethnic or religious identity takes precedence over national civic identity.

In political science literature, uniform voting patterns among immigrant groups often indicate that group identity remains dominant over allegiance to the civic identity of their new country. When immigrants vote almost unanimously for a candidate of their own ethnic background, not because of the candidate’s general policies but because of their shared ethnic affiliation, this suggests that political integration has not taken place. Rather than embracing the rules of the civic political system, in which primary allegiance is to the state and the public interest, they maintain their primary loyalty to their community, religion, or tribe. This is particularly evident when a community is geographically concentrated, maintains separate religious and social institutions, and continues to use its language, culture, and traditional norms. In such circumstances, local politics becomes an extension of community politics rather than part of national politics.

"El-Sayed’s electoral success was not based solely on a general progressive platform. A significant part of his campaign mobilization relied on direct appeals to Muslim and Arab-American communities, emphasizing his Muslim identity and employing sharp populist rhetoric, including repeated attacks on Israel"

The Somali Community and Ilhan Omar

The Somali-American community in Minnesota provides a clear example of this phenomenon. The community functions as a cohesive political voting bloc. Support for Ilhan Omar stems primarily not from an assessment of her policies toward all residents of Minnesota or the United States. On the contrary, she regularly attacks and denigrates the United States and its president. She is elected solely because she represents the Somali community. She has been reelected five times by large margins, even during periods of widespread public criticism of her positions. In other words, regardless of what she does, none of her constituents will challenge her. Ethnic voting, when it becomes the dominant factor, can undermine one of the fundamental principles of representative democracy: the principle of accountability.

Rather than evaluating candidates based on their contribution to the broader American interest, which should also be their own day-to-day interest, Somali voters offer almost automatic loyalty to a representative of their own ethnic background. The result is that the community operates as an independent political bloc, with its own agenda, rather than as part of the broader American public. When this allegiance is sufficiently strong, the conditions emerge for a state within a state: an environment in which norms, priorities, and political representation are determined by the community rather than by the national civic framework. This is not to mention the growing corruption and nepotism. Just a few months ago, one of the largest fraud schemes uncovered in Minnesota came to light, involving the Somali community and a federal child nutrition program established during the COVID-19 pandemic. The scheme involved approximately $300 million. Most of the known individuals involved are of Somali descent, sparking criticism over the concentration of fraud within the community and failures in oversight.

Ilhan Omar | “It seems that no matter what she does, none of her constituents will challenge her"

Abdul El-Sayed Advances an Anti-Israel Agenda

Abdul El-Sayed provides another example of how a Muslim candidate can leverage religious and ethnic solidarity to build a stable support base, particularly among young voters. Recently elected to the U.S. Senate from Michigan (with approximately 52.5% of the vote), El-Sayed did not win solely on the strength of a general progressive platform. A significant part of his electoral mobilization relied on direct appeals to Muslim and Arab-American communities, emphasizing his identity as the son of Egyptian immigrants and as a Muslim, while employing sharp populist rhetoric, including repeated attacks on Israel.

Among young Muslims, support for El-Sayed largely reflected identity-based voting rather than a detailed assessment of his policies. When a candidate is perceived as “one of us,” scrutiny of his positions, their feasibility, or their implications for the broader American national interest tends to weaken. Attacks on Israel often serve as a clear marker of identity: they signal the candidate’s loyalty to the community and enable him to mobilize emotional and ideological support, even when the rest of his platform is not examined in depth. The result is populist voting: almost automatic support as long as the candidate continues to speak the community’s language and attack the perceived enemy.

This pattern exacerbates the problem of immigrant representation. When young Muslims vote for a candidate primarily because of his identity and criticism of Israel, rather than his performance or contribution to the broader public interest in the country where the election is taking place, accountability is weakened. The candidate knows that a substantial portion of his support base will remain loyal as long as he maintains the right symbols and rhetoric. At the same time, an incentive emerges to deepen polarization: instead of bridging the gap between the community and broader American society, the candidate reinforces identity-based divisions.

Abdul El-Sayed | “Among young Muslims, support for El-Sayed reflected identity-based voting”

The Cases of Rashida Tlaib and Jean-Luc Mélenchon (LFI)

The following cases illustrate how candidates and political parties exploit Muslim and ethnic solidarity to build a stable support base, sometimes at the expense of a shared civic identity or liberal-secular norms. They reflect the patterns described above: concentrated identity-based voting, weakened accountability, and incentives for populist politics directed at the community rather than the broader public.

Rashida Tlaib, from Michigan, United States, is an American of Palestinian descent who represents Michigan’s 12th Congressional District, which includes Dearborn and areas with large Arab-American and Muslim populations. She has consistently been reelected by substantial margins as a progressive Democratic member of Congress and is one of the most prominent voices in Congress opposing Israel and supporting the Palestinian cause.

In the 2024 election, while Kamala Harris lost significant support in Arab-Muslim cities in Michigan, including Dearborn and Hamtramck, Tlaib maintained strong electoral performance in these areas. In Dearborn, for example, she received approximately 62% of the vote, roughly twice Harris’s share. This points to clear identity-based voting: the community favors a representative identified with its ethnic background and the Palestinian agenda, even when the Democratic presidential candidate loses support. The district itself is a safe Democratic seat with a substantial minority population, allowing her to secure reelection without significant dependence on her performance in the eyes of the broader public or on criticism of her positions.

This case parallels that of Ilhan Omar: strong descriptive representation, concentrated community support, and relative insulation from electoral punishment. When voters cast their ballots primarily because of identity and positions on Palestine, rather than domestic policy or overall accountability, civic integration and accountability are weakened.

Another prominent example is Jean-Luc Mélenchon and the La France Insoumise (LFI) party in France. Mélenchon, the leader of LFI, has become one of France’s most influential left-wing politicians, largely thanks to massive support from Muslim voters. According to surveys, approximately 70% of Muslim voters supported him in the first round of the 2022 presidential election, while around 62% voted for the LFI list in the 2024 European Parliament elections. This support is particularly concentrated in urban areas with large Muslim populations. Mélenchon has shifted his positions on Islam and secularism. In the past, he defended laws restricting religious symbols in schools and opposed the use of the term “Islamophobia” as a political tool. He later adopted rhetoric emphasizing the fight against “Islamophobia,” defended the right to wear religious attire in public spaces, and placed the Palestinian cause at the center of his election campaign.

The party has been criticized for mobilizing Muslim voters through identity-based appeals, sometimes at the expense of traditional secular positions held by the French left, and for consistently winning in areas where Muslims are overrepresented.

Here, too, the pattern is similar: near-bloc voting along religious and ethnic lines, incentives for the candidate to speak the language of the community, including harsh criticism of Israel, and the prioritization of group solidarity over a shared French civic identity. When a party builds its political strength on such a foundation, it creates a risk of polarization and the erosion of shared secular and liberal norms. It should be noted that in his most recent speech, Mélenchon threatened military intervention against Israel if elected.

“Mélenchon's support is particularly concentrated in urban areas with large Muslim populations.”

From a Voting Bloc to a State Within a State

When ethnic voting is accompanied by demographic concentration, autonomous community institutions, and rejection of majority norms, a parallel social and political dynamic begins to emerge. The community maintains its own informal legal and social system, a separate religious education system, and an inward-looking political structure. The elected representative becomes the community’s envoy to the state, rather than the state’s representative to the community.

In such circumstances, integration fails not only at the cultural level but also at the political level. The state loses its ability to demand full civic loyalty, while the community maintains de facto autonomy. Historical and comparative examples show that as this process advances, areas emerge where state authority weakens and group identity dictates the political agenda.

The Threat of Islamization

Religious identity, particularly Muslim identity, can serve as the basis for a voting bloc similar to one formed around ethnic identity. In some cases, Muslim candidates may exploit religious or community solidarity to establish a stable support base, even when their positions or policies provoke widespread criticism from the general public. This phenomenon is not unique to Muslims, but it has attracted scholarly attention because of demographic characteristics, immigration patterns, and identity politics in Western countries. For example, what would happen if a candidate sought to ban the sale of pork in his town, in defiance of the country’s values? Such a situation would create a clash between religious and national identity.

Studies of religious and ethnic voting in the West indicate that Muslim communities sometimes tend to vote in large numbers for left-wing parties or candidates perceived as representing their community’s interests, particularly on issues such as immigration, anti-discrimination, and foreign policy. Candidates can exploit this tendency through targeted appeals to the community, emphasizing shared identity or making promises concerning sector-specific issues. When support is based primarily on religious solidarity rather than overall performance, there is a risk of weakening accountability: a representative may advance positions perceived as conflicting with prevailing liberal values, for example on freedom of expression, gender equality, or foreign policy, without losing the support of the community.

"Mélenchon shifted his positions on Islam and secularism: having previously defended laws restricting religious symbols in schools, he later adopted rhetoric that placed the Palestinian cause at the center of his election campaign"

In Conclusion

Concentrated ethnic voting by immigrant communities, as reflected in consistent support for Ilhan Omar and other Muslim candidates, is more than an electoral phenomenon. It is an indication of failed integration and the prioritization of community identity over the country’s civic identity. When this pattern becomes entrenched, it creates the conditions for a state within a state: an environment in which loyalties, norms, and political representation are separate from those of the broader society. A liberal democracy cannot survive in the long term when significant segments of its population abandon integration and choose identity-based loyalty over shared citizenship.

The examples presented above illustrate two facets of the same phenomenon. In Omar’s case, the support comes from a geographically concentrated bloc that offers almost automatic loyalty to a representative of Somali descent. In El-Sayed’s case, it involves the broader mobilization of young Muslims through populist, identity-based rhetoric, particularly attacks on Israel. In both cases, voting is based largely on group solidarity rather than an assessment of the candidate’s contribution to the broader American national interest. When this pattern becomes entrenched, it undermines integration, weakens democratic accountability, and creates the conditions for parallel political loyalties: a state within a state.

As for Mélenchon, his case reflects an attempt to court the Arab vote through the cynical exploitation of the Palestinian issue, accompanied by an unmistakable undertone of outright antisemitism. What all four politicians discussed in this article have in common is one thing: they are all anti-Israel and seek to win Arab votes.

“Concentrated ethnic voting by immigrant communities is an indication of failed integration”